Hello,
I have a question after reading many of the articles on your website and your book on how large institutions operate in the Forex market.
A brief background on me: I have read much on supply/demand recently since it instantly caught my attention when I stumbled upon the FF post online. I have also watched most of Sam Seiden’s (free) webinars. I have been considering the OTA courses but have my doubts. I went to one of their seminars just last Thursday and when I asked one of their presenters a question, it was pretty much glossed over.
My main doubts over the commonly talked about theory is the fact that pending un-filled orders cannot move price (as you point out), and that orders surely don’t remain on the table for months/years (again, as you point out).
Anyway, my question to you is regarding time spent at a ‘zone’. You say that more basing is better. Most supply/demand theories say less basing (i.e. less time spent at a zone) is better. My thinking is that the less time price spent at a zone, the less chance there will have been for the big banks to place their required trades, and therefore the higher the likelihood that price will return there. The more basing, the higher the chance that the bank’s required orders will have been completely filled.
Would you mind explaining your thinking further?
Thanks in advance for your time and your website.
Kind regards,
My Response:
Hello,
Thanks for the question.
Sorry yours got glossed over; that’s a common gap, and you’re right to be sceptical.
On the OTA courses: my honest view is that most of their supply and demand theory doesn’t hold up under scrutiny, and the cost is mostly buying access to a community and a signal room rather than knowledge. The test I’d use when evaluating any course is simple — does it give you a mechanism you can reason about, or just a pattern you can recognise? Patterns get memorised. Mechanisms survive changing market conditions.
Now your actual question, because you deserve a straight answer.
Your argument rests on one premise: that a zone exists because institutions have unfilled orders sitting at it, and that time spent in the zone is time spent filling those orders. That covers only one of at least three reasons a zone forms.
1. Institutions placed orders there. A base is very often the footprint of execution, not the remains of an unfilled intention. Those orders are complete by definition. There’s nothing left to fill — the zone is the record of the trade, not a deferred one.
2. Institutions were rejected there and want the same price again. This is the case you describe. It’s real, and it’s the strongest one.
3. Price simply had to transact at that level. Accepted value, someone’s average cost, a prior range boundary. The interest there may belong to participants with no strong reason to revisit — they’ll defend the level without needing to buy it back.
So a long base isn’t evidence that the book got filled. It’s evidence that a lot of the market agreed on that price. And that’s why longer basing tends to make a zone stronger rather than exhausted: the longer price is accepted, the more inventory changes hands there, and the more of the market’s cost basis sits at that level. Price returns to where value transferred — not to where an unfilled order happens to be waiting. The short-lived “zones,” the quick pause in a trend, the single rejection candle — those have no acceptance behind them, and those are the ones that get run over.
One caution, since this shouldn’t be taken as unlimited. Once a zone ages into a wide range over weeks or months, stop treating it as a supply/demand zone. It’s a range. The trade there is buying the low or fading the high, not trading “the zone.” Age changes the structure, not just your confidence in it.
What I actually watch, roughly in order:
- Speed of return. How fast price came back is the single most informative thing, and it reflects remaining interest far better than the base does.
- The reaction at the zone. Did it stop dead, or grind through and keep going?
- Where the zone sits in the higher-timeframe picture.
- Risk:reward at entry. A zone can be genuinely real and still be a terrible trade at 1:1.
- Timeframe. A daily zone can be violated by a five-minute move without being invalidated.
So basing time does matter. I’d just frame it as a measure of how much of the market has agreed on that price — not as a clock counting down an order being filled.
Happy to go deeper on any of it. And if you want a second opinion on the courses rather than a warning, tell me what you’re considering and I’ll give you something more useful than “don’t.”
Best,