Supply & Demand Course Progress

14 of 15 Lessons

Best Timeframes For S&D

Current

Your S&D Trading Plan

Next Steps

Journaling & Tracking Your Trades

Lesson 14: Developing a System for Improvement and Consistency

Reading time: 18 minutes

Download Journal Template Trade Journal Walkthrough FAQs

The Power of Trading Journals

Welcome to the Lesson 14 in our Supply & Demand trading course. Throughout our journey, we've covered numerous technical concepts and strategies, but this lesson may be the most important for your long-term success. Today, we'll learn how proper trade journaling and tracking can improve your decision making and provide data-driven insights.

Key Concept: Trading journals are not just records of past trades—they're the blueprint for your future success. Without proper tracking, you're essentially trading blind, missing critical patterns and opportunities for improvement.

TLDR Summary

A well-maintained trading journal accelerates your learning curve
Track key metrics: win rate, risk-reward ratio, and psychological factors
Use both quantitative and qualitative data to identify patterns
Regular review sessions reveal your strengths and areas for improvement
Digital tools can automate much of the tracking process

Why Most Traders Fail to Journal Properly

Despite its importance, many traders neglect consistent journaling. Here are the common pitfalls:

Lack of Discipline: After emotional trades (both winners and losers), traders often avoid documenting what happened.
Inconsistent Format: Without a structured approach, important details get missed or recorded differently each time.
Too Much Data: Tracking too many variables leads to analysis paralysis and eventual abandonment.
No Review Process: Even traders who record their trades often fail to periodically analyze the data for insights.

Figure 1: Systematic review of trade performance reveals patterns that aren't visible when looking at individual trades.

Essential Elements of an Effective Trading Journal

Your trading journal should capture both quantitative metrics and qualitative insights:

Trade Details

Date, time, market, timeframe, entry/exit prices, position size, profit/loss

Setup Type

Supply or demand zone, fresh or tested, strength rating (1-10)

Risk Metrics

Stop loss placement, risk amount, risk:reward ratio, % risk of account

Market Context

Overall trend direction, market conditions, recent volatility, news events

Screenshots

Before entry, during trade management, after exit with annotations

Psychology Notes

Emotional state, confidence level, distractions, decision quality (1-10)

Trading Principle: The most valuable journaling happens immediately after a trade while your thoughts and emotions are fresh. Wait too long, and hindsight bias will distort your perception of what actually occurred.

Sample Trade Journal Entry

Figure 2: A comprehensive trade journal entry showing pre-trade analysis, execution, management, and post-trade reflection.

Example Journal Entry: EUR/USD Demand Zone Trade

Date & Time:

April 14, 2023 - 09:45 EST

Market & Timeframe:

EUR/USD - H4 Chart

Setup Type:

Fresh Demand Zone (Strength: 8/10)

Overall Trend:

Bullish on Daily, Pullback on H4

Entry Price:

1.0865

Stop Loss:

1.0825 (40 pips below zone)

Take Profit:

1.0945 (Supply zone from previous week)

Risk:Reward:

1:2 (40 pips risk, 80 pips reward)

Position Size:

0.5 lot (1% account risk)

Result:

Win - Full TP Hit (+$800)

Pre-Trade Analysis:

EUR/USD was in an overall bullish trend on the daily chart. Price had made a strong push upward creating a fresh demand zone during Asian session. The pullback to this zone aligned with a 38.2% Fibonacci retracement level, adding confluence. Zone showed clean, impulsive departure with minimal consolidation - a hallmark of institutional buying.

Trade Management:

Price initially went against my position by 15 pips but remained inside the zone. After 2 hours, bullish momentum returned with strong buying pressure. Moved stop loss to breakeven once price moved 30 pips in favor. Took partial profit (0.2 lot) at the halfway point to lock in some gains. Rest of position hit full target during New York session.

Psychological Notes:

Initially felt nervous when price dipped after entry, but stuck to my plan because price remained in the zone. Confidence level pre-trade was 8/10 due to multiple confluence factors. Had slight FOMO during entry as price was already showing signs of reversal, but waited for pullback into zone. Overall decision quality: 9/10 - followed plan with discipline.

Reviewing and Analyzing Your Journal

Recording trades is only half the battle—regular analysis is where the real growth happens. Schedule weekly or monthly review sessions to:

Identify your most profitable setups (e.g., fresh demand zones vs. tested zones).
Spot recurring mistakes, such as premature entries or poor risk management.
Track your win rate and average risk:reward ratio over time.
Assess psychological patterns, like overtrading during volatile sessions or hesitating on high-probability setups.

Pro Tip: Use filters in your digital journal to isolate specific trade types (e.g., all EUR/USD trades or all H4 timeframe trades). This helps you drill down into what’s working and what isn’t.

Interactive Quiz: Test Your Knowledge

Why is it critical to journal trades immediately after execution?

To satisfy regulatory requirements

To capture emotions and thoughts while they're fresh

To share with trading communities

Previous Lesson Next Lesson